So, the time has come for you to promote someone from your team to a more senior position, but how do you choose between employees? You don’t want to get it wrong because that could be a costly mistake for you all, but your team all seem pretty good, so what do you do? Here are a few things that should help you come to the right conclusions about your team so you can pick just the right person for the position, no matter what it might be:
- Observe Your Team in Action
Before you do anything else, it would be a really good idea to spend some quality time observing your employees in action. Watching them as they work will help you to work out who is the most efficient, who is able to take the lead when necessary, who is unflappable under stress, and a million other things that will help you to work out which one of them is ready for the particular promotion you have in mind at any given time.
- Data, Data, Data
Numbers don’t lie (usually). Start gathering data on performance metrics, project completions, sales numbers, and any other quantifiable achievements. But remember, data is like a bikini; what it reveals is suggestive, but what it conceals is crucial. Don’t rely solely on numbers. They should inform your decision, not be the entire basis of it.
- Think Feedback
It’s a good idea to ask for feedback from every corner of the company when the time has come to promote someone. Why? Because if you talk to managers, peers, clients and customers (if it is appropriate to do so) you will get a much better measure of your employees, which you can then use to your advantage to promote the fight person.
- Leadership Theories in Action
Dust off those management books and apply some leadership theories. Does Jane show transformational leadership qualities that could inspire her team to new heights? Does John apply the principles of servant leadership, putting his team’s needs before his own for the greater good? Applying these theories can help identify who has the potential to not just lead, but lead effectively and positively. Think of it as matching personality profiles on a dating site, but for promotions.
- The Trial by Fire
Give potential candidates a trial project or temporary leadership role. See how they handle the heat when they’re at the helm. Do they flourish or flounder? This method can be incredibly telling because nothing tests metal like fire. Plus, it gives individuals a fair shot to prove they’re more than just their resume.
- Cultural Fit and Future Vision
Consider not only who is right for the role now but who will help lead the company toward its future goals. Does this person embody the values and culture of your company? Are they capable of driving the vision forward? Sometimes, promoting for potential rather than just performance can lead to more dynamic, forward-thinking leadership.
- The Feedback Loop
Once you’ve gathered all your intel, don’t forget to close the feedback loop. Let candidates know where they stand, what they did well, and where they can improve. This not only helps those who didn’t get promoted this time but also sets the stage for ongoing development and future opportunities. After all, tomorrow’s leader might just need a bit more polish today.
- Ethics Check
In the game of promotions, ethics play a crucial role. Ensure your decision-making process is transparent, fair, and free from biases (unconscious or not). It’s easy to favor people who are like us, but diversity in leadership often brings fresh perspectives and innovation.
- Communication is Key
When the decision is made, communicate it effectively. Ensure that those promoted understand why they were chosen and what is expected of them in their new role. For those not promoted, offer constructive feedback and tangible goals to improve their chances next time. Clear communication can prevent misunderstandings and keep morale high.
- Utilize Succession Planning
Implement a robust succession planning process to ensure a continuous flow of capable individuals ready to fill key roles. This involves identifying potential future leaders and providing them with the necessary skills and experiences over time. It’s a proactive approach, like training understudies for a Broadway show. When the star needs a break, you have a talented performer ready to take the spotlight, ensuring the show goes on without a hitch.
- Encourage Self-Nomination
Create a system where employees can express their interest in advancement opportunities. This not only empowers your team but also gives you insight into who is genuinely interested in taking on more responsibility. It’s like having a suggestion box for promotions, where employees can throw their hat into the ring, ensuring you might uncover hidden gems who are ready for advancement but haven’t been on your radar.
- Peer Evaluations
Integrate peer evaluations into the promotion process. Sometimes, peers see strengths and weaknesses in candidates that managers might miss. This method also promotes a sense of fairness and transparency within the team. Think of it as crowd-sourcing your review process – it’s democratic, inclusive, and can provide a more holistic view of a candidate’s capabilities.
- Regular Performance Reviews
Instead of annual reviews, implement more frequent performance evaluations. This keeps goals and expectations fresh and allows for ongoing adjustments in employee development plans. It’s like having regular check-ups, which can prevent minor issues from becoming major problems and keep everyone focused on their growth and improvement.
- Innovative Reward Systems
You might also want to look behind the traditional paths to promotion and try out alternative reward systems too. Looking beyond traditional forms of promotion and giving benefits like flexible working or project-based bonuses is a good way to help all of the people in your company thrive, even if they are not being promoted to a higher position, and watching how they take these new rewards can help you work out who they are when the time does come for promotion.
- Transparent Criteria for Promotion
Make things easy for yourself and your employees by coming up with a clear and accessible criteria for promotion. That way, the process will not be so mysterious and everyone will have the same opportunity to go for the goal. Not only that, but you will have a very clear way of judging them against one another too.
- Address and Remove Bias
It’s always a good idea to ensure you are not biased against any employees when you are promoting. You can do this by taking some DEI training or even using blind review processes when hiring, so that everyone has a fair shot, and you can find the best person, even if someone on the hiring team has a blindspot.
- Celebrate All Contributions
Oh, and although you might have now narrowed down the field to work out who you want to promote to those top positions, it’s important to still take some time to celebrate the contributions of the staff members who may have not made the cut this time. This is important because it helps to keep staff morale high and show everyone that their contribution is valued even if they weren’t promoted this time.
Promoting the right person often feels like an impossible task to achieve, but it is so important because it will help you to run a more effective and efficient business without wasting your time and mone on recruiting a dud, and as you van see, it is actually a lot less difficult than you might have imagined, if you implement all of the above, anyway.
Post your comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.